Turning vegetarian was "trendy" in the 1980s and has since become
more commonplace. But be it for health, religious, moral or taste
reasons, the extent to which individuals truly go vegetarian is highly
variable.
Research from the US shows that less than one percent of Americans
are true vegetarians, that is, who never eat meat, fish or poultry
although they may eat foods derived from animals such as dairy products
and eggs. The number of vegans -people who avoid all animal-derived
foods, including honey -is even smaller.
How healthy are vegetarian diets?
The healthiness of a vegetarian diet largely depends on the variety
of foods consumed. Because vegetarian diets feature primarily plant
foods, they tend to be richer in dietary fibre, carbohydrates and many
vitamins and minerals.
Protein is a nutrient that many vegetarians worry about, but quite
unnecessarily. While vegetarians typically eat less protein than
non-vegetarians, their diets tend to meet or even exceed the recommended
daily allowance for protein. And if they eat a variety of different
plant foods -grains, nuts, seeds, legumes, vegetables and fruits -the
quality of the protein is fine.
"In the past, we used to tell vegetarians to mix their plant foods at
each meal", said Julie Howden, a nutritionist and executive director of
the Singapore-based Asian Food Information Centre (AFIC). "This is
because plant foods supply different types and amounts of amino acids,
the building blocks of proteins. It was thought that you had to eat all
of the amino acids at one meal to provide good quality protein. People
were therefore taught to have rice with beans or cheese with bread."
"However, this approach is not necessary. Nutritionists now believe
that eating a variety of plant foods every day is sufficient to meet
one's protein requirements."
Fat and cholesterol
Vegetarian diets also enjoy a reputation for being low in fat and
cholesterol. But this is true only if the intake of nuts and fats is
kept low.
According to Ms Howden, "People on vegetarian diets would do well to
heed the general advice about healthy eating: keep fat intake low.
Choose polyunsaturated and monounsaturated fat spreads and oils and low
fat dairy products."
Vitamins and minerals
There are a few nutrients which may be at-risk in a vegetarian diet.
For people who exclude all sources of animal protein, including eggs and
dairy products, deficiencies in iron, zinc, calcium and vitamin B12 are
more likely. It is therefore important to seek nutritional counselling
before embarking on such a diet.
"Nutritionists and doctors often see young women who have gone
vegetarian for whatever reason and given up red meat," said Ms Howden.
"As a result, they may become iron deficient or anaemic." Dietary
sources of iron are needed to off-set iron losses through menstruation.
Good plant sources of iron include dried beans, green leafy vegetables
and dried fruits.
"Plant sources of iron are nowhere near as well absorbed as meat,"
said Ms Howden. "If people have given up animal products altogether, it
is important they choose larger servings of iron-rich plant foods and
eat them with a source of vitamin C such as a glass of orange juice."
Vitamin C helps the body to absorb iron. In some cases, an iron
supplement may be required.
Vitamin B12 is another nutrient that may be at risk. Although the
body only needs a very small amount of vitamin B12 and body stores can
last for some years, nutritionists recommend that vegetarians who do not
consume dairy products or eggs eat foods that have been fortified with
vitamin B12 or take a vitamin supplement.
How far do you go?
Compared to the general population, vegetarians appear to be at lower
risk for heart disease, colon cancer, diabetes, obesity and high blood
pressure. Not everyone however, believes it is necessary to eliminate
meat for successful disease prevention.
"You can achieve many of the same types of health benefits with a
diet that includes meat," said Ms Howden. "You just need to choose lean
meats and remove any visible fat."
Even proponents of vegetarianism agree that it is hard to determine
the extent that lifestyle impacts on the health statistics of
vegetarians. Vegetarians are more likely to be health conscious -they
tend to abstain from alcohol and smoking and to exercise regularly. It
is these factors that experts agree exert a powerful health impact.
The bottom line is for those who have adopted vegetarian diets or are
making gradual changes in that direction remains the same as with
conventional diets: eat a wide variety of foods including plenty of
whole grain products, vegetables, legumes and fruits and maintain a
healthy lifestyle.
Vegetarian diets are healthful and nutritionally adequate when
carefully planned. Consuming adequate amounts of iron and calcium is
especially important. The following foods are good sources of these
nutrients.
Iron: dried beans, spinach and other green leafy vegetables,
dried fruit. To improve iron absorption, consume vitamin-C rich foods at
the same time.
Calcium: Milk, yoghurt, cheese, calcium-fortified soy milk,
calcium-fortified tofu, broccoli, green leafy vegetables.
Variations on a vegetarian theme
Different types of vegetarian diets are characterised by the degree
to which they exclude animal foods. Below are some diets most commonly
thought of as vegetarian yet some people today call themselves
vegetarian if they eat meat just occasionally.
- Pesco-vegetarian -include fish, dairy products and eggs.
- Lacto-ovo vegetarian -includes eggs and dairy products.
- Ovo-vegetarian -includes eggs.
- Vegan -excludes animal-derived foods of all types.